New Year, New You, New Politics?
This week’s Courier Herald column:
It’s a new year. Gyms are packed this week. Sales of diet plans and related foods are peaking. It’s going to be different this year, we all tell ourselves. We’re going to do better.
Resolutions. I’m sure the root word has some meaning of “lies we tell ourselves to make us feel better about all evidence to the contrary.” We mean well but eventually we return to work, routines and reality hit us in the face, and too often nothing changes.
Resolutions are frustrating because the exercise reveals two distinct things about us. We can identify problems and areas to do better. We are also unwilling to commit to resolve and invest in substantive positive change. Then we laugh it off, knowing we’re just like everybody else, despite knowing we’re not being our best.
Our politics often follows a similar path. We know we should act better as individuals, and hold those that represent our views to higher standards. And yet, in a clear race to the bottom, we refuse to let the other side get ahead of us. It’s a course with no winners where in the end, we will all be losers.
There is an opportunity for a fresh start in Georgia. We have a new Governor and Lieutenant Governor. Many fresh faces are joining the legislature. Like the warning on an investment prospectus, past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Georgia has used the last decade to seize opportunities in the wake of the great recession. We’re a top destination for employers and job seekers alike. Our economy is growing. Our budget is balanced. We have money in the bank. Along the way we’ve committed new billions to education, transportation, and investments in industries of the future.
Until now, the state has also largely eschewed the hyper-partisan nature of Washington D.C. and worked toward solving actual, real world problems. It helps that the Governor and legislators actually have to balance a budget, but there’s a lot more to local politics that is different.
Coalitions in Georgia have never had to be partisan. Save for the two years between the 2002 and 2004 elections, the Governor’s mansion, House, and Senate have been led by the same party since at least Reconstruction. While the majority party has generally decided the agenda and the final flavor of most legislation, coalitions that decide major bills have mostly been built along geographic lines. Modern examples have generally been voting blocs of urban, rural, and suburban voters, with Atlanta’s growing suburbs often deciding swing votes.
We have increased investment in Georgia’s transportation infrastructure by $1 Billion per year and provided a transit governance model that works for urban and suburban Atlanta because of bipartisan cooperation. We have eliminated the backlog of rape kits awaiting testing in the GBI crime lab which provided links to 321 existing cases and identifying two serial rapists. This would not have been done without bipartisan work.
As we enter 2019, too many appear ready to bring national talking points to the capitol. To be clear, this is the politics of division. It includes a mindset that for one side to win, the other must lose.
Georgia has prospered because we usually manage to avoid this kind of thinking. Atlanta isn’t Birmingham because it was the city “too busy to hate”. Georgia is the “number one state to do business” because we focus on outcomes and growing, not victory by dividing and taking from within.
Georgia’s political resolutions should be easier than our personal ones. Wholesale changes aren’t required, though temptation to take the low road must be avoided. Republicans can ill afford to govern as conquerors, and Democrats run the risk of moving legislation hard to the right should they take a hyper-partisan approach to the legislature.
It’s a new year. 2018 is over. We can come together as we have always done for the betterment of the state, or we can stoke divisions between us preparing for the next campaign.
It’s not clear which party would benefit from the latter approach. The danger of division, however, is that Georgia would end up the loser.
Add a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
We can only hope and pray!
This legislative session will be a great test of rather or not this state is a beacon of moderation in the sea of hyperpartisan chaos. Let’s see what happens with RIFRA, Open carry everywhere at all times (except the GA Capitol), the take-over of ATL airport, fixing the broken elections system to enfranchise rather that disenfranchise certain demographics, fixing the broken healthcare system across the state etc.
I think Kemp has a unique opportunity to govern responsibly in the interest of ALL georgians, lets see what he does with it.
A noble goal. I think a majority of the left and right despise the gutter that we all occupy nowadays. And in terms of Georgia politics, the toxicity from Washington has made it impossible to separate Atlanta from DC.
Here is the perspective from many on the left: mainstream politics (we’re talking, major party nominations and campaigns for significant state-wide or national posts) before Donald Trump were ugly, but really the main divide was policy. We can disagree on taxes, health care, education, you name it. But ultimately (hopefully) we saw decency in the people across the aisle. It was like that cousin at Christmas – – you’ll spend some time jabbing at each other here or there, but eventually you put the debate aside, refill your wine glass, pig out, and enjoy each other as family.
But, to many on the left today, post Trump, the visceral disagreement isn’t over policy. It is this: we feel as if the Republican party has fallen very, very low on the decency level, the character level. We no longer respect, as a person, and indeed despise, as a person, the leader of the opposition party. That is devastating to the hope of fixing politics in 2019.
When a substantial portion of this country thinks that the President of the United States is a bad human being, fundamentally, it makes it difficult to put that aside, especially for liberals who by and large are more inclined to caring about the means of something more so than purely the ends said means achieved.
And we become very disappointed when our Republican brothers and sisters and cousins, people of whom we believe to be decent and possess character, remain silent when the leader of their party routinely displays his immorality and divisiveness. Republicans have put policy objectives over decency.
My Republican friends don’t want their children behaving like the president, yet they sanction this president’s behavior with their silence and at times, vocal support. It is this that literally depresses many Americans. Why do you allow policy goals to overshadow the basic necessity of decency and character? And it is this obstacle that will prevent better politics in the future.
I know many Republicans are going to be offended by this. They’ll play the “what about” game referring to HRC’s “basket of deplorables” comment or Obama’s “they cling to their guns and religion” comment as evidence that the left is also complicit with where we are today. But I implore everyone to be honest and fair. Do those types of regrettable remarks truly compare in scale to the rhetoric from Donald Trump? No.
Until we as Americans prove that we can be honest with ourselves we will never be able to be honest with each other. And if there’s no honesty, there’s no civility.
You’re right but you give too much credit/blame to Trumpism. The nation has been deeply divided for well over 100 years. Yes, Trump is the most divisive figure in modern history but it’s because we’re at at crossroad in history where the people who’ve been in absolute control are feeling vulnerable. The majority is about to become a minority and this disruption has produced a strongman like Trump. I have no doubt he will fabricate some excuse to declare an emergency so that he can live out his fantasy to become like his self proclaimed “lover” Kim Jong Un. This maybe what it takes to reign him in.
This will get worst before they get better. This state has traditionally handled change better than most but that could quickly change. I hoping and praying that Kemp doesn’t govern the way he campaigned but a lot of people are watching him like a hawk.
Here’s a look at an interesting parallel to Trump in American history:
https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2018/11/13/andrew-johnson-undermined-congress-cabinet-david-priess-book-222413